Saturday, June 23, 2007

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Heidegger is Heidegger

And that's it! Except I will now spend inordinate amounts of mental energy saying very little, but I do love to see my writing filling the pages with my flowing thoughts. Language being language, after all. What more is there to say? How can you possibly argue against (or for) such a tautology? Well, since it is a tautology, I suppose it is after all true...
I found Heidegger even more tiresome, if that is possible, than Derrida, who actually began to make some sense after a while. It seems to me that he is desperately searching for an actual point to make, but other than asking some profound questions and not really answering them, he fills the page with near mysticism. Calling is calling, the called are called, wanderers are, I must assume, are wanderers, and things are things, are they not? Speaking is speaking, and speaking of it now, drivel is drivel, is it not? It seems only fitting that the essay ends with a restatement of the poem used as a sounding board for his thoughts, as he repeats himself with the often times annoying consistency of Phillip Glass.
I now want to set my textbook on fire.

Thursday, May 24, 2007

Exorcizing Derrida's Ghost

I survived our brief encounter with the "big D", but am I unscathed? I'm afraid not. I need to write a note as a form of post-Derridian therapy, so I can move on to next week's readings (so don't feel compelled to read these ramblings of a destabilized mind).
A comment from Greg stuck in my mind after our class: he said something to the effect that despite what Derrida says in his essay (seemingly negative comments about books and writing), he actually believes the opposite -- that he is playing devil's advocate with us. I think this may be true and it raises one of my beefs against the post-structuralists, generally: that they seem to avoid taking sides (post-structuralist sophistry, perhaps). While this can be frustrating and it leads to the circular and often verbosely repetitious writing styles they employ, it must have a purpose. One can hope, at least!
My guess is that it is a deliberate attempt at what Greg called 'destabilization'. Derrida, as I recall from a previous traumatic exposure to him (from which I had almost recovered), was uncomfortable writing about philosophy while working and teaching in a traditional university Philosophy department. He thought you couldn't easily critique something that you are a part of. In a 'famous' interview (with someone, somewhere) he said (approximately) that, "to understand your culture, you must critique it; but how can you critique it when you are a part of it?" From this, I infer that he is saying that, no matter what our field of endeavor, we all carry 'baggage' that interferes with our complete objectivity and true understanding. It is from this baggage-laden starting point that we begin to argue a position on something (any philosophers out there who can help me out with this?). Derrida seems to argue both sides of every question (or to take a deliberately provocative point of view in order to irritate us into seeing things differently) in order to free himself from his own baggage -- he tries to get outside of the subject (be it writing, philosophy, culture). I was enlightened (somewhat) by the comments Derrida made in the interview we watched -- about how his writing was freer and more honest than his speeches (logos VS. phonos?). Perhaps his writing is a kind of stream-of-consciousness that helps him to overcome his own presuppositions -- to get outside the box -- hence, the circular and often contradictory nature of his writing. Now, if only he had a good editor ! But then who could make enough sense of it to edit his writing into something clear and concise - and besides that would kill the 'deconstructing-Derrida' industry that flourishes in many universities.
Thanks to my earlier intensive post-Derrida therapy sessions, the only other things I remember from my previous encounter with him was a quote from my philosophy professor: he said, "Derrida gives nonsense a good name" -- and who am I to argue with a philosophy professor, given my own presuppositions and baggage!
. . . there, I feel better now. . . . On to Heidegger.

Friday, May 18, 2007

"Against Theory"

In light of the previous post, I thought that this might be a good time to mention that the question of theory has been an extremely hot topic of debate, particularly since its "rise to power" after World War Two. There is an enormous body of work that debates this question. The contributions to this debate range from both advocates, skeptics, and those on neutral ground. You could easily develop an excellent term paper on this topic. The following is a brief bibliography of materials that are pertinent to this debate (in-progress):

Ellis, John Martin. Against Deconstruction. If you find yourself annoyed with postmodernism and deconstruction some afternoon, and feel the need to read something that confirms all of your most negative criticisms of these movements--this book is for you. However, even if you love Derrida and other avatars of deconstruction, you will probably get a kick out of it. Elis mounts a vicious attack against deconstruction and spares Derrida absolutely no mercy. He treats many of the passages that we will discuss in English 364 from Of Grammotology and Dissemination.

De Man, Paul. "The Resistance to Theory." This is a classic essay, unfortunately omitted from our anthology; the topic is accurately reflected in the title. I strongly recommend it. It is in the anthology by Lodge and Wood, on reserve at Bennett.

Christian, Barbara. "The Race for Theory" (pp. 2255-2257 in the anthology). During the late 1980s, French Deconstruction, gender and queer theory, and a wide variety of other movements, were gaining popularity very rapidly. Although Christian does not consider herself "anti-theory," she believed that theorists were going overboard--at the expense of literature. During these years, and in to the 1990s, many universities were battlegrounds for those "for theory" and those "against." Christian claims to stand in the middle (although some of her latter essays will demonstrate that she profited from her contributions to theory quite well. In general, the trenches that separate the "theorists" and "non theorists" is much calmer these days.

Knapp and Michaels. "Against Theory" (pp. 2460-2474 in the anthology). The title of this essay is an accurate description of its contents. Should "theory" as a specialty be abandoned?

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

Are Literary Critics Vampires?

OK - I'll give this a try . . .
One of the things that always troubles me is the relationship between literary criticism and theory and the actual creative endeavour of writing. The act of creating a poem, a play or a piece of fiction is usually undertaken (I believe) without any thought to theory (with the exception of 'academic' writers, such as A.S. Byatt perhaps, who may write from a knowledge of critical theory). Most writers write what they know -- based on their personal experiences, interests and/or personal research.
Once an important work is out in the world, it seems to me, literary critics then feast upon it, tearing it apart and compartmentalizing it to fit some genre and theory. Some published criticisms of books that I've read (I'm refering here to criticism written by academics, not lay people or journalists) has succeeded in sucking all the life out the work to such an extent that I don't feel like reading it -- even though it may be a great piece of literature.
I remember a radio interview with Ian McEwan when his novel 'Atonement' came out. The interviewer asked him what this and that 'meant' in the novel. He coyly skirted around the question. McEwan (and most other good writers) is smart enough to know that it is not his job to interpret his own work -- that task lies with the reader and with the herds of academics who analyze his works in undergraduate classrooms (providing a big boost to the sales of his novels). Some day one of these critics will tell him what his book was about and what school of theory it fits.
So, here's my question: does critical theory enhance our enjoyment of literature (and inspire new creative works) or is it a separate industry that gives academics and intellectuals opportunities to write hefty, profound and at times inpenetrable tomes to baffle the rest of us (and push them happily along the publish or perish 'tenure-trail')?