In light of the previous post, I thought that this might be a good time to mention that the question of theory has been an extremely hot topic of debate, particularly since its "rise to power" after World War Two. There is an enormous body of work that debates this question. The contributions to this debate range from both advocates, skeptics, and those on neutral ground. You could easily develop an excellent term paper on this topic. The following is a brief bibliography of materials that are pertinent to this debate (in-progress):
Ellis, John Martin. Against Deconstruction. If you find yourself annoyed with postmodernism and deconstruction some afternoon, and feel the need to read something that confirms all of your most negative criticisms of these movements--this book is for you. However, even if you love Derrida and other avatars of deconstruction, you will probably get a kick out of it. Elis mounts a vicious attack against deconstruction and spares Derrida absolutely no mercy. He treats many of the passages that we will discuss in English 364 from Of Grammotology and Dissemination.
De Man, Paul. "The Resistance to Theory." This is a classic essay, unfortunately omitted from our anthology; the topic is accurately reflected in the title. I strongly recommend it. It is in the anthology by Lodge and Wood, on reserve at Bennett.
Christian, Barbara. "The Race for Theory" (pp. 2255-2257 in the anthology). During the late 1980s, French Deconstruction, gender and queer theory, and a wide variety of other movements, were gaining popularity very rapidly. Although Christian does not consider herself "anti-theory," she believed that theorists were going overboard--at the expense of literature. During these years, and in to the 1990s, many universities were battlegrounds for those "for theory" and those "against." Christian claims to stand in the middle (although some of her latter essays will demonstrate that she profited from her contributions to theory quite well. In general, the trenches that separate the "theorists" and "non theorists" is much calmer these days.
Knapp and Michaels. "Against Theory" (pp. 2460-2474 in the anthology). The title of this essay is an accurate description of its contents. Should "theory" as a specialty be abandoned?
Friday, May 18, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment