OK - I'll give this a try . . .
One of the things that always troubles me is the relationship between literary criticism and theory and the actual creative endeavour of writing. The act of creating a poem, a play or a piece of fiction is usually undertaken (I believe) without any thought to theory (with the exception of 'academic' writers, such as A.S. Byatt perhaps, who may write from a knowledge of critical theory). Most writers write what they know -- based on their personal experiences, interests and/or personal research.
Once an important work is out in the world, it seems to me, literary critics then feast upon it, tearing it apart and compartmentalizing it to fit some genre and theory. Some published criticisms of books that I've read (I'm refering here to criticism written by academics, not lay people or journalists) has succeeded in sucking all the life out the work to such an extent that I don't feel like reading it -- even though it may be a great piece of literature.
I remember a radio interview with Ian McEwan when his novel 'Atonement' came out. The interviewer asked him what this and that 'meant' in the novel. He coyly skirted around the question. McEwan (and most other good writers) is smart enough to know that it is not his job to interpret his own work -- that task lies with the reader and with the herds of academics who analyze his works in undergraduate classrooms (providing a big boost to the sales of his novels). Some day one of these critics will tell him what his book was about and what school of theory it fits.
So, here's my question: does critical theory enhance our enjoyment of literature (and inspire new creative works) or is it a separate industry that gives academics and intellectuals opportunities to write hefty, profound and at times inpenetrable tomes to baffle the rest of us (and push them happily along the publish or perish 'tenure-trail')?
Tuesday, May 15, 2007
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Oh,
You ask a BIG question, for which there may be no answer. The world is complex and chaotic.
It would appear that Aristotle, from my reading was an instigator in the notion of rigidly codifying and categorizing everything. Did you get that sense too? But then I thought, perhaps Aristotle simply tapped into a deep psychological need to understand the world and classification is one of a number of possible crude systems that help us to abstract the infinitely complex and chaotic real world and give an imaginary, separate chunk that can be thought of in isolation, because the whole is overwhelming. The falseness of this imitation of the world gets us humans into trouble when we mistake this classified, extrapolated chunk of reality for the real thing. If our tools are crude, it follows for me that our made-up realities must also be crude , flawed, incomplete.
Your chosen author was right to smile and say little, an attitude I admired also in Yann Martel, when he was asked to explain "Life of Pi", and pretty much refused. Martel essentially said that he shouldn't be the one to determine the reader's reality, an eminently sensible position.
For me, I hope to see criticism differently than as a vampire. I don't want to suck the life from any writer, but to understand a little of what they might have been thinking about when they wrote, or what sort of plot mechanics were employed. Classification for me is a gross tool to roughly differentiate types of writing that I wish to read about. I wouldn't rely on such a gross tool to think that once I'd pigeonholed a writer into a particular slot that there they would stay or that there they should stay. For me, classification is just one of the tools I employ to determine whether or not I enjoy a writer's scribblings throughout my life. As I read, their words vibrate through my consciousness, expanding my horizons and possibilities in new and exciting ways.
I know that writers are just like me in some ways and not like me in other ways. They are, each and every one of them, unique, as am I. I want to look at the "good" and "bad" messages from their words (I believe that most writers write because they feel they have something to offer to other human beings - I may be mistaken :) ) and roll them over in my mind, finding the flaws in the writer's thinking (there are always flaws), logic, plot structure, or overall message. I find there is always something else to learn about a writer or their writing, another thing just around the next corner, because as I stated in the outset, the world is infinitely complex and chaotic, and writers are a part of this complex, chaotic world. Like me.
This certainly is an important question. As I alluded to at the end of last week's class, "theory and criticism" has indeed become a major industry, and relies upon a steady stream of commodifiable scholarship. Yet, as I hope to demonstrate in this course, both "theory" and "criticism" represent a broad range of materials, genres, and disciplines. While some of the writings that have been admitted to the canon of "theory and criticism" engage in often merciless dissection of texts--as alluded to by Kieran--others engage in open-minded debates about language, meaning, and worldviews. In addition, there are many writers such as Borges, Wilde, and Nietzsche, that blur the line between fiction and theoretical writings (we'll take a look at some of them), and take a harsh stance on traditional literary criticism.
As Brian mentions in the previous comment, Aristotle--for all his brilliance and originality--helped to establish many of the [dreaded] conventions of modern criticism; the compulsion to categorize, establish fixed conventions, and maintain hierarchies. Yet, Aristotle helped to legitimize the study of literature--against the better wishes of Plato. In addition, his legacy was so strong, that many artists were inspired to break with it and create radical and very anti-Aristotelian forms of art.
One of my favourite examples of the literature-criticism hybrid is Oscar Wildes "The Decay of Lying" Unfortunately, it is not in the Norton Anthology). This piece takes the form of a dialogue--an obvious parody of the Platonic dialogue. One of the interlocutors states that it is not "art that imitates life," but "life that imitates" art! In "The Critic as Artist," Wilde provides a similarly unusual perspective on the role of the critic that might be of interest.
In the spirit of writers like Wilde, Nietzsche, and others, I think a great way to deal with critics—both those that are appealing and otherwise—is to consider their importance in intellectual history. In this way, it is possible to read even the most annoying work of criticism and appreciate its importance in the history of ideas, rather than its status as a “theory” that we need to either embrace or reject.
Hi Kieran,
The introduction in our anthology (p. 1-7) does a nice job of showing the inescapability of critical theory. Suppose I like a certain genre – let’s say Fantasy. Now as soon as I ask the question, “why do I like this genre more than other genres?” I am engaged in theory. If I want to know exactly what it is about Fantasy that resonates with me, I am engaged in theory. If it makes me feel good, I will appeal to an expressive theory, no matter how undeveloped it is. Etc. Thus, the point is that the choice is not between theory and no theory, but between self-consciously developed theory and undeveloped theory. Even the most hard-core anti-theory theorist practices theory!
This leads me to my second point and it has to do with my own preferences. I think the opening sentence in the introduction (1) is extremely helpful in understanding the aims of theory. Fundamentally, there are two kinds of theory: Theory as AID and theory as END. AID theory helps us understand literature on its own terms. What devices does an author use? Why are some constructions effective and others not? What structures are common to a particular genre? Etc. Theory as AID helps me understand why I enjoy the literature that I do. Personally, I find this kind of theory very helpful and enjoyable. I once took a children’s literature course with Prof. Kathryn McArthur at the University of Waterloo. She spent a lot of time on theory, examining the basic structures of children’s literature. It was the best class I ever took for I began to understand why some books resonated with me and others did not.
Theory as END is entirely different game. It seems to me that this approach simply USES literature to serve the theorist’s own agenda. A scholar has an axe to grind and imposes his/her program onto the text. The text now becomes a tool, fashioned in the image of the author, to fight against competing theories. When theory is used as an END, the text becomes a mirror image of the theorist. In my view, when theory is practiced in this way, it can ruin literature. Instead of indwelling the world of the text and reading it sympathetically - instead of enjoying the text from within - the text becomes a slave of the theorist. Now I am not opposed to agendas. I have a particular worldview just like everyone else. But before I think it is important to honour the text and let it teach me before I subjugate it to my purposes. The bottom line is that I prefer theory as AID over END.
Garry has suggested an interpretation of critical theory as "aid" and "end in itself", showing a preference for one over the other.
I would argue that both forms (and others) have their place though, and I don't necessarily wish for one more than the other - at this point, I am receptive to learning about both (and more!).
Garry, shouldn't your example go one step further back, and ask "Why do I like this writing over others?" In your sentence, you've already identified that there are things called "genres", and that they are imbued with certain properties. You're right, I think, that theorizing and classification seems inescapable. But... aren't the wide-spread concepts of classification - like genre, and what constitutes what belongs to each genre - arbitrary and motile? I remember my Shakespeare course where some of the later plays are referred to today as "romances". The First Folio doesn't list them that way though. Our modern day analysis of the plays and historical and critical perspectives have lead some theorists to theorize that the First Folio *should have* listed these plays differently, and if THEY were in charge, dammit, they would have!! Darn, it seems that classification doesn't work after all. ;-)
Now I realize you didn't intend to set off a firestorm of protest and I have no real desire (except for my dark, subconscious ones) to start a fire. I too like the idea of using theory and criticism to heighten or aid my enjoyment of literature. I however am beginning to see that the rants of self-appointed ubermen/uberwomen critics with far-out and fantastical notions can change, enlighten, heighten my entire world-view, at least for a while while I mull over what they have to say and talk to other people about their rantings. This broadening of my world-view will only enhance my love for poetry and prose, I am sure. As long as I keep a an eye on my goal, my desire: to love and enjoy the art of reading and writing. I hope to even enjoy the nuts, or shelve them and say "Ah well, not for me..."
Sure some critics seem to exist merely to criticize, thus the old saw about the competency of such individuals from those who feel their bite. They might still have a point though, or maybe not directly in one reading of one of their works, but combined with their life and other people's writings... who can tell where the worth of any writer lies?
I'm thinking as I write this of Edgar Allan Poe, who was a very influential critic in 19th Century America. Really? until a few days ago, I thought he was just a loon who wrote strange, bizzare tales of woe. But it turns out that much of his criticism, for which he is little remembered by peons like me, has had influence with other thinkers of his age and beyond. His tales of woe though, are also in a very real way, criticism against the outpouring of the transcendentalists and their brand of individualist-as-supreme, the so-called "man thinking" of Thoreau. I found this fascinating, and it gave me a whole new appreciation for his angle on criticism.
So, I don't think that any writer, no matter how much I dislike them, will be able to harm literature. In order to be able to do that, wouldn't there have to be something fundamentally wrong about literature in the first place, so wouldn't these critics in effect be right?
Kieran,
The words "A.S Byatt" caught my eye immediately, so I felt compelled to comment, even though it will not be as lengthy or loaded with terminology as everyone else's. Forgive the thursday post-work-brain - definitely not the most productive.
Having read Byatt's work last semester, I must say initially I suffered through it - "Angels and Insects" appeared to be dry, verbose, oddly post-modern. Byatt to me, failed to smoothly incorporate her intertexts and at times, the mix of fiction and documents was quite awkward. However, her rich variety of references made every single moment of "suffering" worthwhile! As I got deeper into the work, read up on how carefully and how intensely important her characters' names are to their behaviours, I appreciated her work a lot more. No longer a bore, or a vampiric drainage, Byatt's writing became more of a puzzle. I caught myself laughing on the bus when I found two references to Othello. Very gratifying:)
Likewise, I guess the process of understanding and untangling all these critical and heavily loaded discursive pieces of work is then almost something of an "inside joke" - an academic version of feeling included once you actually get it:) So, to your question: do we need to become "critical fiends", breaking apart every little strand of poems, articles, books? Is that opposite of the author's original "creative mode"? I'll choose to tackle a portion of this spin-off and say, that any reader/writer is a critic, and is always influenced by what they have read/seen in the past. Thus, I don't think that we are ever one or the other (Simulacra, much? haha) Rather, I believe that instead of worrying that criticism "picks apart" at the author's work, we should consider the contrary: what if the work was never to be noticed at all? I believe negative/positive reviews are equally beneficial, since it is impossible to please everyone and create a singular interpretation for any piece of literature. Critics aid in the continuation as well as modification of discourse. Not to tread on Garry's points though. Here's another question to throw out there: is there a certain type of power behind being a critic? Is there a form of manipulation behind theorizing and does criticism perhaps allow us to engage in "subordinating power-dynamics" with various texts? (Maybe those are the dark subconscious Freudian dynamics, Brian? just kidding)
I think that's all i can come up with at the moment. To be continued...
Stacy
To Pick up on Stacey's last point, the first thing that comes to mind are the many poets whose widespread fame is largely the result of critics' attention: Mallarmé (Derrida and others) and Hölderlin (Heidegger), for example. This is not to imply that either critic did not already have a huge following. However, the amount of people who read these--and other poets--due to these critics is substantial.
On a slightly different note, I wanted to comment on what Brian said about Aristotle above. Although--as we discussed in class--Aristotle seems to provide us with the basis of a system of "rigid classification" (and there can be no doubt of that), he also provides us with a system of lying! One of the many passages that we did not get to on Wednesday night (section 9)--but will get to when we begin with Nietzsche next week--condones lying in the service of "universal truths." Many read this as standing in contradiction to Aristotle's other dictums. Yet, here in the midst of a tract that is famous for its advocacy of the notion that "art should imitate life," we have several lines that encourage artists to bend and warp the truth to serve the greater needs of universal truth. These lines hover in the background of Nietzsche's "Truth and Lies," and the defense of Shelley (and other Romantics) that we will take a look at.
Post a Comment